Comics : Ultimate Spider-Man #64

Staff Only
Edit Review
Edit Title

This story is part of an Arc: "Ultimate Carnage"
     Part 1 / Part 2 / Part 3 / Part 4 / Part 5

This review was first published on: 2004.

Background...

Gwen is dead, and Peter may well be to blame.

Peter trusted Curt Connors, a doctor whose past experiments resulted in the Lizard and Venom, with a sample of his blood, which Connors explained could start a revolution in medicine and save lives. Connors then went on to use Peter's father's work on the experiment, coupled with some of his own genetically-enhanced DNA.

The result? A serial-killing organism that took Gwen's life, and now seems to be after Peter himself.

In Detail...

Ultimate Spider-Man #64
Oct 2004 : SM Title
Arc: Part 5 of "Ultimate Carnage"
Editor:  Ralph Macchio
Writer:  Brian Michael Bendis
Pencils:  Mark Bagley
Inker:  Scott Hanna
Cover Art:  Mark Bagley
Staff Only
Issue
Review
 Reprinted In: Spider-Man TPB (Ultimate) #11
 Reprinted In: Ultimate Spider-Man Reprints (Hardcover) #6

The organism, who, for lack of a better name, I will call Carnage, starts to resemble Peter again. Peter orders Connors back to his lab so that the doctor can find out how to kill it, threatening to throw it in a room with Connors himself.

What unfolds is a battle in the middle of the night where Peter blames himself for this creature. HUMAN pieces of garbage he can handle, but murderous, mutated clones of himself? Peter thinks he's failed completely, but has little more time to ruminate when Carnage attacks and kills two more cops. Carnage takes on a very familiar form, closely resembling Peter's late father.

Connors returns to his lab to find Peter waiting for him. Peter explains that the creature was looking for Peter to stabilize its own DNA (which is why it attacked the others). The face we kept seeing wasn't Peter's... it was Peter's father's face. Peter stopped thinking and let instinct take over. In a clear-cut case of him-or-it (emphasis on it: Peter didn't see it as any more than a spore or a virus), Peter threw the creature down a smokestack. Peter again threatens to kill Connors, but naturally doesn't follow up. Later, Connors goes to a police station and turns himself in.

The next morning, MJ asks if Peter caught the guy. Peter also announces that he's done with Spider-Man.

Ben Reilly shows up at work, and the dean tells him that his and Connors' experiment are what killed the guard (wait... Smitty? I thought his name was Sam.). Since Connors is in custody, the lab is closed, and Ben is out of a job. Ben asks if he can get his things from the lab. While no one is looking, Ben takes a test tube marked "Parker: Sample #2" and takes it, with a slight grin on his face.

In General...

This arc felt complete. In less time than "Venom" took, the "Carnage" storyline mostly redeemed the concepts of Carnage and the clone saga simultaneously, making them both more compelling with less information given.

Repercussions: Gwen dead, Connors in jail, Reilly at large with a sample, in a final page that might as well say "This ain't over." No readers take Peter's resignation seriously, of course, but the turmoil comes through loud and clear. Peter is legitimately asking himself what Spider-Man's contribution to society is, which should make the next issue all the more interesting.

Overall Rating...

Well, I'm surprised that Bendis et al made Venom readable. I'm positively shocked at what he was able to do for Carnage. I like the Parker legacy as recurring theme in the Ultimate Spider-Man mythos, and I look forward to seeing it in the future.

Still, the book's a harder sell without Gwen. The next issue will tell us all why we should buy this book without her.