Comics : Peter Parker: Spider-Man (Vol. 2) Annual 1999

Staff Only
Edit Review
Edit Title

This review was first published on: 2004.

Background...

J.M. deMatteis is a great writer. Man-Thing is a classic character. The Scriers were a ret-con looking for a justification. Can this annual deliver the goods?

In Detail...

"Song of The Man-Thing"
Peter Parker: Spider-Man (Vol. 2) Annual 1999
Year 1999 : SMURF 445.850 : SM Title
Editor:  Ralph Macchio
Writer:  J.M. DeMatteis
Artist:  Al Rio, Dan Schaeter, Liam Sharp
Staff Only
Issue
Review
Articles: Aunt May Parker, Mary Jane Watson-Parker

With annuals, you have all those extra pages - and there's usually three choices as to what to do with them.


  1. Write a standard story, and pad the rest with a short story and/or picture galleries, character summaries, etc.
  2. Take a standard story, and streeeetch it out with extra fight scenes or graphic art sequences.
  3. Take the opportunity to run a more-than-usually-complex story without having to split it over multiple issues.

This one's a bit of the last two mixed together. The story is indubitably above the norm for complexity.

The original Scrier from the cult of Scriers, is returned. He's a being of great power, who originally formed the cult, but who has been absent for a very, very long time. (I should mention here that I thought the reworking of Scrier, in the final days of the Clone Story, was appealingly devious - and I think it's great to see these guys back in action.)

He drops into a meeting of modern Scriers, searching for one to be his agent in an ambitious task - to gain control of The Nexus of All Realities - currently under the protection of Ted and Ellen Sallis (as documented in the as-yet unpublished final issues of the late lamented Strange Tales).

Spider-Man gets drawn into the tangled plot, and is then launched into a sequence of alternate realities, in an indirect battle for control of the Nexus. This involves a mixture of conventional and computer-enhanced artwork, merged with earthly and cosmic story-lines.

To be completely honest, I didn't fully understand exactly what was going on here. I'm not fully familiar with the background of the Man-Thing, and the subtleties of the differences between the human and cosmic aspects of the personalites kind of left me behind. But, it's still a good story... and one that does motivate me to see if I can pick up a few issues of the highly-rated Man-Thing title, and possibly even some original Strange Tales, to see if I can figure out exactly what was happening.

That's not to say that I didn't enjoy the story. There's plenty there to keep the reader interested on the earthly level. Peter Parker and Spider-Man is recast into some interesting situations, worth of deMetteis' creative pen. This is a story which has a little something for everyone.

In General...

Those who are less familiar with Man-Thing and the Nexus (myself among them) are probably going to struggle a little with this. I'm guessing that long-time Marvel fans are going to love it. Am I right?

Overall Rating...

To me, this was a 3.5 web effort. I suspect that old-timers would rate it more highly. It certainly appears well-constructed, and the graphic art guys put some hours in. If you're a serious Marvel Fan, I think you'd want this on the shelf.